
Official Interlocutory Motion under Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 CPC in Probate & Testamentary Suits
1. Legal Rules: Order 39 CPC & Sec 268
When a family member or executor propounds a contested Will and secretly moves to sell, develop, or mortgage estate real estate, caveators face a unique procedural hurdle. An ordinary civil court injunction draft often fails in probate proceedings because the Probate Court is fundamentally a court of conscience, not a court of title.
While landmark Supreme Court judgments in Chiranjilal Shrilal Goenka v. Jasjit Singh (1993) 2 SCC 507 and Kanwarjit Singh Dhillon v. Hardyal Singh Dhillon (2007) 11 SCC 357 establish that a probate court cannot determine disputed ownership between the testator and third parties, Section 268 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 expressly mandates that the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 regulates all proceedings of the District Judge. Under Section 269 ISA read with Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC, the court holds comprehensive plenary power to freeze property, restrain alienation, and preserve the subject matter of the estate until the validity of the Will is decided.
Applies the entire Code of Civil Procedure to probate cases, empowering judges to hear interlocutory motions under Order 39.
Grants explicit statutory authority to the District Court to interfere for the immediate protection and custody of the estate.
Converts the petition into a regular contentious suit upon caveat entry, giving full plaintiff and defendant litigation standing.
2. Tripartite Test in Testamentary Suits
In Dalpat Kumar v. Prahlad Singh (1992) 1 SCC 719, the Hon'ble Supreme Court settled the three indispensable pillars for temporary injunctions. In a contested probate or testamentary suit, these tests operate under specialized evidentiary thresholds:
The applicant does not need to prove absolute ownership of the property. Instead, you must show: (a) Caveatable Interest under Section 283/284 ISA (e.g. you are a natural heir who would inherit under intestate succession); and (b) Credible Suspicious Circumstances surrounding the Will, such as physical or mental infirmity of the testator, exclusion of direct heirs without reasons, or active execution by the sole legatee.
Irreparable injury means damage that cannot be cured or compensated by money. If the respondent sells the ancestral home or land to a third-party builder, third-party rights intervene, title registers are mutated, and multi-year partition suits follow. Once destroyed or developed, the unique corpus of the family estate is lost forever.
The court balances whether withholding the injunction causes more injury to the applicant than granting it causes to the respondent. Because the respondent holds no granted probate, freezing property transactions preserves the status quo with zero permanent loss to anyone. If the Will is genuine, the respondent can sell after the final decree.
3. Order 39 Application Draft
Use this comprehensive interlocutory application format in High Courts or District Courts exercising testamentary jurisdiction. It establishes caveatable standing, sets out specific alienation threats, and prays for restraining orders against both respondents and local registration authorities.
4. Irreparable Injury Affidavit Format
An Order 39 application in a testamentary court is defective without a supporting affidavit sworn under Order 19 CPC. This affidavit establishes personal knowledge of the applicant, verifies the urgency of site threats, and affirms the lack of adequate monetary remedy.
5. High Court Status Quo Restraining Order
When presenting your case during urgent mentioning, your counsel should propose explicit restraining terms to ensure the order covers both physical possession and registry mutation. Here is the standard High Court status quo restraining order text:
6. Injunction Risk & Urgency Evaluator
Assess your legal standing and determine the exact interlocutory remedies warranted for your case. Select your relationship to the deceased, primary Will challenge ground, and observed threat of property alienation:
Urgent Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 Application + Caveat Notice to Sub-Registrar
7. Probate vs Title Injunction Comparison
Understanding the legal distinctions between an injunction in an ordinary title suit and an injunction in a probate proceeding is crucial to avoid summary rejection of your application:
| Key Legal Metric | Probate Injunction (ISA s. 268) | Civil Title Injunction (SRA s. 38) |
|---|---|---|
| Core Subject Matter | Preservation of the estate corpus in custodia legis until Will validity is tried. | Adjudication and declaration of absolute ownership, title, and lawful possession. |
| Prima Facie Burden | Prove caveatable interest as intestate heir + suspicious circumstances of Will. | Must establish clear title chain, registered sale deed, or adverse possession. |
| Executor Authority | Executor has no right to alienate prior to probate (Section 211 & 213 ISA). | Transfer governed by Section 54 of Transfer of Property Act, 1882. |
| Court Fee on Injunction | Nominal miscellaneous application fee (₹10 to ₹100). No ad-valorem fee. | Often requires ad-valorem court fee based on property valuation or fixed slab. |
| Breach Consequences | Order 39 Rule 2A civil prison + sale declared void ab initio (Surjit Singh). | Order 39 Rule 2A contempt + lis pendens under Section 52 Transfer of Property Act. |
8. High Court Testamentary Rules Matrix
Rules governing temporary injunctions and caveats vary across Indian High Courts exercising original testamentary jurisdiction:
Caveat must be filed under Rule 397 within 14 days of service of citation. Once caveat is entered and affidavit in support filed under Rule 399, the petition becomes a Suit. Interim applications are filed as Interim Applications (IA) on the Original Side.
Testamentary cases over ₹2 Crores are tried on the Original Side. Order 39 applications are listed before the Roster Judge. Urgent mentioning for status quo requires advance notice to the propounder or compliance with Rule 3 proviso.
Governed under Chapter XXXV of Original Side Rules. Caveat stays grant for 8 days pending affidavit. Once converted to contentious cause, Master of Court registers as a testamentary suit for injunction.
In all mofussil districts across India, Principal District Judges try probate petitions. Section 268 ISA directly invokes CPC Order 39, and appeals lie under Order 43 Rule 1(r) to the High Court.
9. Step-by-Step SOP: Stopping Estate Sale
Follow this sequential 6-step litigation protocol to freeze estate alienation as soon as a suspicious Will is propounded:
Lodge Form 12 caveat in the High Court or District Court where probate is sought. This ensures no ex-parte grant can be issued without serving mandatory notice upon you.
Within the statutory timeline (8 to 14 days), file your detailed affidavit disclosing suspicious circumstances. The court automatically converts the petition into a Contentious Testamentary Suit.
Move an application under Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 CPC read with Section 268 ISA, accompanied by the sworn verification affidavit detailing broker advertisements or property visits.
Appear before the Bench and establish immediate danger of alienation. Urge the court to pass an ad-interim status quo order restraining sale, leasing, and encumbrance.
Obtain certified copies of the restraining order and officially deliver them to the Sub-Registrar of Assurances and Municipal Corporation to freeze deed registration and Khata mutations.
If the respondent attempts to violate the injunction, immediately file an application under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC for civil imprisonment and property attachment.
10. Injunction Breach & Rule 2A Contempt
Parties who knowingly violate or circumvent an injunction order in testamentary proceedings face severe statutory penalties under the Code of Civil Procedure and settled Supreme Court jurisprudence:
- Attachment of the violator's personal properties for up to 1 year.
- Detention in Civil Prison for a term extending up to three months.
- Sale of attached properties to compensate the injured legal heirs.
In Surjit Singh v. Harbans Singh (1995) 6 SCC 50, the Supreme Court held that any conveyance, mortgage, or agreement executed in defiance of an injunction order is unlawful and void. The purchaser acquires zero title or equity, and the court will restore original possession.
11. Landmark Case Laws & Precedents
Every lawyer and litigant arguing an Order 39 motion in probate must cite these authoritative precedents:
Supreme Court of India: The probate court has exclusive jurisdiction to decide the genuineness of the Will. It cannot adjudicate title, but holds custody over the estate until grant.
Supreme Court of India: Affirmed that grant of probate does not confer title where the testator had none. Protection of properties during the suit is essential to prevent third-party chaos.
Supreme Court of India: Established the golden tripartite test of prima facie case, irreparable loss, and balance of convenience governing all interlocutory injunction grants.
Delhi High Court: Held that under Section 268 of the Indian Succession Act, the court hearing a probate petition is fully competent to grant temporary injunction under Order 39 CPC.