4. Primary Medical Board Certification Format
The treating doctor and two hospital experts write their first view within 48 hours. Copy or print this clear form for the ICU file:
Download Primary and Secondary Medical Board approval formats and the 48-hour Judicial Magistrate (JMFC) intimation draft for India. Aligned with the January 2023 Supreme Court order in Common Cause and ICMR DNAR clinical rules.

Hospital Medical Board Execution Pack: Primary Opinion, Secondary Board Countersignature & 48-Hour JMFC Notice
When a patient with a valid Living Will enters an Intensive Care Unit (ICU) and cannot speak, doctors cannot stop breathing machines on a verbal family request alone. Indian law requires a strict two-tier hospital check to protect the patient.
In Common Cause v. Union of India (2018), a five-judge Supreme Court bench recognized the right to die with dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution. However, the 2018 rules forced families to wait for a Judicial Magistrate and doctors with 20 years of service.
On 24 January 2023, the Constitution Bench issued a landmark Modified Order (MA No. 1699 of 2019) to fix those delays. The Court kept the two-tier board safety check, while making it practical for hospitals to act within hours instead of months.
Most online portals still share old 2018 summaries and give no draft forms for the doctors or hospital heads. Below, we provide ready-to-use drafts for the Primary Board report, the Secondary Board approval, and the 48-hour JMFC notice.
Use this interactive checker to review a live ICU case under the 2023 Supreme Court rules. Pick the clinical stage, Living Will status, and board stage to see the exact next legal step.
Patient is in an advanced stage of an incurable disease. Life support only delays natural dying without hope of recovery.
Valid under the Jan 2023 Supreme Court order. Hospital confirms the copy against the custodian or digital health record.
Both the Primary Board and CMO-backed Secondary Board have confirmed terminal futility within 48 hours each. Take written surrogate consent, start full pain care, and intimate the JMFC.
The Supreme Court requires two separate boards so no single doctor acts alone. Review how the two boards differ in makeup, timing, and legal duties under the January 2023 order:
| Protocol Feature | Primary Medical Board | Secondary Medical Board |
|---|---|---|
| Who Forms the Board? | Hospital where the patient is admitted | Hospital + District Chief Medical Officer (CMO) |
| Member Composition | Treating physician + at least 2 subject experts | 1 CMO-nominated doctor + at least 2 other independent experts |
| Doctor Experience Rule | Minimum 5 years (reduced from 20 years in 2023) | Minimum 5 years (must not sit on Primary Board) |
| Target Decision Time | Preferably within 48 hours of referral | Preferably within 48 hours of Primary opinion |
| Main Duty | Check terminal illness, Living Will copy, and futility of machines | Do an independent bedside check and confirm or reject Primary view |
| Magistrate (JMFC) Role | Not involved during Primary Board review | Hospital sends written notice to JMFC after both boards agree |
The treating doctor and two hospital experts write their first view within 48 hours. Copy or print this clear form for the ICU file:
After the Primary Board signs, the Secondary Board checks the patient within 48 hours. Use this form for the CMO doctor sign-off and family consent:
Under the 2023 Supreme Court order, hospitals do not wait for prior judge orders. Before stopping life support, the hospital sends this written notice with board reports to the local JMFC court:
The treating physician confirms the patient is terminally ill and lacks decision-making capacity. The hospital verifies the Living Will against the surrogate's copy or digital custodian record.
The hospital forms a Primary Board with the treating physician and at least two subject experts who hold at least 5 years of experience.
The Primary Board examines the patient, checks all scans and labs, and signs its opinion preferably within 48 hours of referral.
If the Primary Board supports withdrawal, the hospital sets up a Secondary Board including one doctor nominated by the District Chief Medical Officer (CMO) and two independent experts.
The Secondary Board checks the patient independently within 48 hours and confirms the decision. The appointed surrogate or next of kin signs informed consent.
Before stopping artificial life support, the hospital sends written notice with all board reports to the JMFC. Full pain relief and palliative comfort care continue without break.
The ICMR Consensus Guidelines on DNAR work alongside a Living Will in India. They guide ICU doctors when chest shocks or CPR cannot save a dying patient.
Stopping a breathing machine or noting DNAR never means leaving a patient alone. Doctors must keep full pain relief and bedside nursing active until natural death.
A DNAR form stops futile CPR when the heart or lungs fail in terminal illness. It does not stop medicine or nursing care unless both medical boards sign off.
Doctors must give safe pain medicine and keep mouth and skin care active. Close family members get calm bedside time without fear of legal blame.
A 76-year-old man with late-stage cancer falls into a deep coma. His daughter gives the hospital his Living Will naming her as surrogate. Within 48 hours, three Primary Board doctors sign a futility note. Next, the District CMO picks a doctor for the Secondary Board. Within 48 hours more, the second board signs off. The hospital mails notice to the JMFC, and life support stops with full pain care.
Sometimes a hospital stalls out of legal fear, or the two boards disagree. The family or hospital can then file a fast writ case in the High Court under Article 226. The Chief Justice forms a fast bench to check the ICU file and pass clear orders.
Why Write a Living Will Now?
A clear Living Will keeps your family safe from hard ICU choices. You decide your care before an emergency hits. Your loved ones know your exact wishes in writing.
Simple 2023 Notary Rules
You can write a Living Will on plain white paper with zero stamp duty. Sign it in front of two adult witnesses and get a local Notary or Gazetted Officer stamp.
How Our Legal Team Helps
Our team drafts clear Advance Medical Directives and property Wills in simple words. We also help families and hospitals prepare two-tier Medical Board records fast.